Tadeáš Čop (el 09/11/14 a las 7:15 pm)
Alyssa P. (el 06/09/14 a las 5:11 am)
Woah woah woah... How are there 28 million views when there are only 7
thousand ppl in the world?
Clash of Clans | MCH GaMinG (el 25/09/14 a las 7:22 am)
At the sart i can see this movie sucks!
Ozymandias (el 05/09/14 a las 5:09 am)
This movie touched me. I mean it. I love Middle-earth and this was clearly
made with a love for Tolkien's works and a respect of Peter Jackson's. I
was amazed at how excellent the writing was and the acting was superb.
Never cheesy or over the top. It felt exactly like Middle-earth should.
Thank you for this, it is a gift truly appreciated.
belongaskip (el 17/10/14 a las 8:20 pm)
I'm sure this movie is a most worthy effort but it just seems utterly shit
in comparison to PJ's movies.
Jody Wilson (el 02/10/14 a las 11:04 am)
Im not sure tolkien had earings on the heirs od isildur
Charles Jones (el 31/08/14 a las 6:25 am)
I learned tonight that this existed and immediately came to view this made
for internet film. My initial interest was in Elladan and Elrohir, for I am
a huge fan of the elves. However, I found this an example of a Labor of
Love and an homage to J.R.R. Tolkien by devoted fans. It is well made, well
acted, and received by me with immense gratitude. For every loving
depiction, true to Tolkien's lore adds to our enjoyment.
I Thank everyone who played any part in the making of this Film. I
recommend it highly and without reservation. I Hope to see similar works
come forth in the future, perhaps some focusing more on Glorfindel, Elrond,
Elladan, and Elrohir, oops, and of course Arwen.
Castiellya Lawson (el 17/11/14 a las 7:16 am)
so much better than the 60s soviet union hobbit movie and the animated
cartoons.(and I should know about the ssr one, the version on youtube is
parody subbed but I spea Russian, ur not missing any.)god I love Tolkien
and his world......came here because of the elves, stayed because of my own
rabid lotr fangirling
HelfyreTwilight (el 26/10/14 a las 11:36 am)
I really enjoyed this, as a LotR fan. I read the books years before the
films came out and cheered enthusiastically when I saw the trailer a year
(or two?) before The Fellowship of the Ring.
My critique of the film: Sound; the action sequences were loud. That may be
purposeful due to the attention-garnering tactics in an attempt to make it
seem more intense. Conversely, all of the dialogue scenes were WAY too
quiet, I thought something was wrong with my speakers, I could barely hear
the actors speaking with the volume turned all the way up (which I never do
to prevent them from blowing out). The volume of the background music was
in between both aforementioned volumes (ad therefore also too loud). IMO
the volume of each should be: Action loudest, but only a few decibels above
dialogue and NEVER so when there is dialogue during the action. Background
music should be a decibel just beneath the dialogue, except where
appropriate to more strongly convey the scenes emotion where appropriate.
Writing/Directing; The love triangle Elbereth (forgive my spelling I
may have her name wrong) was involved in (both between her and Arathorn and
her male friend) was interesting in terms of dramatic tension but could
have been done without as it was entirely too predictable. From a tactical
standpoint, and I know this wasn't intentional, however this is what
happened: Galryne got Elbereth killed. If she hadn't decided to "help"
Elbereth may have survived the orc attack because Elbereth literally spent
half her energy and focus trying to keep the foolish woman alive, which is
depicted five seconds after she emerges from hiding. She was squeamish and
cringing holding a blade, she had NO business doing so. In my opinion it
made her character slightly less likeable. Yes, people make mistakes but
before that moment she was not depicted as a fool. She had a blade and was
inside as a last-man-standing if Elbereth fell outside. Arathorn's death
seemed like it was trying too hard to look like Boromir's death in
Fellowship, which completely broke my suspension of disbelief. It was very
dramatic and cool in Fellowship, but something different should have been
done for Arathorn. Example, he could have fought with the orc head-on and
after defeating the orc, succumbed to his wounds. This would be both
honorable and believable. On top of that it was completely overshadowed by
Elbereth's death in acting. Arathorn, a seasoned warrior, would have known
YOU DO NOT PULL ARROWS OUT OF YOUR BACK on the battlefield! You break them
off and leave the heads in until you find help or you could do worse damage
and bleed out. If his lung was punctured, which is what it seemed to have
been, it is unlikely he’d have survived long enough to say goodbye at the
end, much less talk. If it didn’t hit his lung…or his heart…he may have
Critique aside, this is an EXCELLENTLY done film! The acting for the most
part was really good, the costuming was superb for a low-budget, the
writing was very well done, directing of the action sequences and cutting
of the film both were great and it was all done with a superb love and
dedication of Tolkien’s original work. This is a very good addition to the
LotR series! I would love to be a part of projects such as these. Alas, I'm
in North America. Hats off to Actors at Work!
SirOrrin Freeman (el 27/08/14 a las 1:36 am)
What about Rohan, and Gondor! couldnt they assist the Dunidin?